• Home • VEI Main Site • Econometrics • Search •

Skoog & Toppino Article

Challenge Issues Challenge Cases


Actual Earnings Use
Average Statistics
Basic Analysis Methodology
Broad Support
Census Bureau Caveat
Chronic Disability
Corcione Article
CPS Data Validity
CPS Definition of Work Disability
CPS Self-reported Disability
CPS Use by Other Researchers
Daubert/Kumho Standards - WLE
Employment, Earnings, & Disability
Expert Qualifications
First Work Disability Question
Hale Article
Hamel Letter
Heterogeneity
Medical Impairment Ratings
Multi-year Data Averaging
Offset Use
Possibility of Future Disability
Residual Capacity
Sample Selection Bias
Skoog & Toppino Article
Temporary Disability
VALE Software
Veteran's Disability

 

Usual Opposition Position
Skoog, Gary R. and David C. Toppino.  "Disability and the New Worklife Expectancy Tables from Vocational Econometrics, 1998:  A Critical Analysis."  Journal of Forensic Economics, 12(3), 1999, 239-254.  

Skoog and Toppino had a variety of objections to the worklife tables, including:

 
VEI Position
Full response to all issues raised in this article can be found in the monograph published by VEI; a condensed version of the monograph was published as:

Gibson, David S. and John P. Tierney.  "Disability and Worklife Expectancy Tables:  A Response."  Journal of Forensic Economics, 13(3), 2000, 309-318.  

John McNeil, formerly of the Census Bureau, has also authored a response

Other answers to specific issues can be found on this website.  

 
Related Challenges
Anglin v. Reed Bowman v. McClendon McGonigal v. Lucas
Petridge v. Hewlett-Packard Scott v. Pyn Wright v. Werner
 
Related Articles
Gibson Monograph Gibson & Tierney McNeil Response

Last modified: Tuesday April 03, 2007 02:58 PM


Several links in this site are to documents that require the Acrobat ® Reader ® software.  Click logo for information on this free software
Questions or problems regarding this web site should be directed to VEI Webmaster.