| Usual Opposition Position |
| The usual position is that the article by Thomas Hale published in the Monthly Labor Review states that the Current Population Survey (CPS) is inappropriate for studying the employment experiences of persons with disability. |
| VEI Position |
| The June 2001 issue of the Monthly
Labor Review contains an article written by Thomas Hale, an economist employed by the Bureau of Labor Statistics
(BLS). The article criticizes the CPS as a data source for studying the
employment experience of persons with a disability as measured by the
Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Hale’s goal as an employee of BLS is to find/develop a survey to enable measurement of the employment experiences of persons with a disability as it is defined by the ADA. The CPS, however, does not use this definition, nor is this definition the best one to use when assessing lost earnings. Other key criticisms in the article deal with the validity of the first work disability question (limited in the amount or kind . . .) and the presence of persons with a temporary disability. Hale's criticisms of the CPS are not new. They are either irrelevant to the worklife expectancy calculations contained in The Tables, or are not substantial enough to warrant discontinuing use of the CPS for estimating the worklife expectancy of persons with and without work disability. His reservations are contradicted by many leading researchers who use the CPS data to study the impact of disability.There is no official government position against use of the CPS to define work disability. In fact the Census Bureau regularly generates cross-tabulations of this data and publishes it on its web site. In fact, two noted former Census officials (McNeil and Miller) have authored affidavits to the validity of CPS for measuring work disability. |
| Related Challenges | ||
| Achtar v. Green | Franks v. Caito | |
| Mesman v. Crane | Wright v. Werner | |
| Related Articles | ||
| Gibson (2001) | Gibson & Tierney (2000) | Skoog & Toppino (1999) |
Last modified: Tuesday October 14, 2008 03:34 PM
